Despite my North American origins, I’m not a fan of flaky pastry when it comes to pie and tart shells, whether they be sweet or savoury. If I want to encase something delicious in flaky pastry, I’m going to use rough puff pastry. For pies and tarts I use my all-butter shortcrust pastry recipe.
Whether you call it shortcrust, as we Australians do, or pâte brisée, as the French do, it’s essentially the same recipe. My recipe calls for egg yolks to enrich the dough, as do some of the French versions.
By ensuring all your ingredients stay well chilled, you can avoid the mistakes that lead to a tough finished pie crust. I actually find the shortcrust dough to be very forgiving and, no matter how many times I re-roll the offcuts, the baked pastry remains tender and short.
The ratios for this homemade shortcrust pastry produce enough dough to make a double crust for a 25cm (10 inch) pie. To demonstrate my method of lining and blind baking a tart shell, I’ve used a full batch of this pâte brisée recipe to line the 30cm diameter, 3.5cm high, fluted tart tin for my Zucchini Spiral Tart with Green Pea Salsa Verde.
I’ve also used a batch of this pastry to line the 31cm x 21cm x 3.5cm fluted rectangular tart tin in my Leek and Gruyère Tart recipe [LINK]. My Fancy Hot-Smoked Salmon Quiche recipe [LINK] doesn’t require a full batch, and I’ve noted the necessary adjustments in that recipe to line the 13cm x 26cm x 3.5cm fluted tart tin. I’m an err-on-the-side-of-caution baker and generally don’t attempt to adjust a pastry recipe to the exact needs of my selected tin. I’d rather have to be creative about what to do with the offcuts, or stash them in the freezer waiting for inspiration, than be short of pastry dough on the day.
Let me step this all-butter shortcrust pastry recipe out for you.
Ingredients
Pastry dough:
- 625g all-purpose flour
- 315g unsalted butter
- 90g egg yolks
- 1 ½ teaspoons table salt
- 60g iced water – inclusive of 1 teaspoon apple cider vinegar
Egg wash:
- 2 egg yolks
- 1-2 tablespoons of full cream milk
I use all-purpose flour in my shortcrust pastry recipe as it ensures that the pastry is manageable, without being too short from using cake flour or straying towards tough from using bread flour.
The 90g of egg yolks are generally achieved with 5 large eggs. If I’m a bit short with 5 eggs, I add in a bit of egg white to get it to 90g.
Shortcrust pastry method
Make some space in the fridge and freezer
If you’re patient and use your fridge and freezer as described, this recipe will not fail to produce tender and short pastry even on the hottest Australian summer day!
The keys to success are having the ingredients well chilled before you start and by returning the pastry dough to the fridge or freezer after completing each step in the recipe. My pastry routine starts with clearing space in my fridge or freezer to hold the measured ingredients, rolled out pastry dough, and the formed tarts.
Weigh out 315g chilled unsalted butter and cut it into 1.5cm cubes. Store it in a sealed container in the fridge until needed. I also weigh out the dry ingredients, 625g all-purpose flour and 1 ½ teaspoons table salt, into another sealed container and put it in the fridge.
Whether you use a stand mixer with a pastry beater attachment or a large food processor for this shortcrust pastry recipe, the bowls and attachments can also be chilled before you start making the pastry.
Making the pastry dough
Add a handful of ice cubes to a 250ml jug, top with cold water and set aside. Next, place a 500ml jug on your digital kitchen scales and zero out the scales. Add 1 teaspoon apple cider vinegar to the jug, followed by iced water (without the ice cubes) to the weight of 60g.
Zero out the scales a second time, and start separating 5 large eggs, adding the yolks to the jug one at a time until you’ve added 90g of yolk. If I’m slightly short after 5 yolks, I use some of the leftover egg white to make up the weight. Whisk until well combined and place the egg mix in the fridge until required.
For the record, for homemade shortcrust pastry, I never rub the butter into the flour when I make pastry. It certainly wouldn’t work on warm days in Australia and, when the goal is to keep the butter chilled, rubbing it with warm fingers is not going to achieve that goal.
Until recently, I used my large 11-cup capacity food processor to make this homemade shortcrust pastry dough. But I’ve since swapped to my KitchenAid and its pastry beater attachment. With the stand mixer, I’m far less likely to overmix the dough, which keeps the gluten in check and the pastry tender and short. The regular paddle attachment can also be used, but it will take more time to break down the lumps of butter.
I have also successfully used the Smeg stand mixer with its flex edges beater attachment. All the shortcrust pastry I made while on The Great Australian Bake Off Season 6 was made using Smeg equipment.
Add the all-purpose flour, salt and chilled and cubed unsalted butter to the stand mixer bowl with the pastry beater attachment. Mix on low, up to a maximum of speed 2, until the mixture resembles coarse sand.
With the mixer on low, gradually drizzle in the egg mix until the pastry dough comes together and starts to form large lumps, then stop. Don’t overmix.
If using a food processor, pulse the flour, salt and chilled butter cubes together. The result will not be as consistent as the stand mixer but aim for coarse sand. There is little risk of overmixing at this stage. Then drizzle in the egg mixture with the motor running. Stop when the dough starts to clump together.
Finishing the shortcrust pastry on the benchtop
Turn the shortcrust pastry out onto the kitchen bench. Flour is not required at this stage. Using a pastry scraper (often called a bench scraper), gather the lumps of dough together and start to press it into a rough loaf shape.
I avoid using my hands as much as possible when I bring the dough together to form a cohesive block of dough. The French method is called fraisage, where you smear portions of the dough away from you with the heel of your hand. This smears larger bits of butter into streaks. But with the stand mixer or food processor method, the butter is already broken into fine pieces. Instead, my shortcrust pastry recipe uses the method of cutting and stacking the dough multiple times with a pastry scraper.
Cut the dough in half with a pastry scraper and stack the two pieces on top of each other. Press the dough down firmly and reshape into a rough loaf shape. Repeat 3 to 4 times. The all-butter shortcrust pastry dough does not need to look perfectly cohesive at this stage.
Using a pastry scraper, shape the shortcrust pastry dough into a rectangle and wrap in plastic wrap or place in a sealed container. Let the dough rest in the fridge for at least 3 hours or overnight. This is an important step to allow the gluten to relax and prevent shrinking when you bake the tart crust. It also ensures that the liquid is well absorbed into the flour, which will make the dough more pliable and less likely to crack as you roll it.
Lining a tart tin my way
My rolling set-up
Tough, dry pastry often comes from adding extra flour as you roll. I don’t flour the bench at all. Instead, I roll the shortcrust pastry between two silicone mats. Two sheets of baking paper will also do the job. Invest in at least two silicone mats, because they’ll help you get excellent results with your pastry and many of your other bakes. I own several mats sized 30cm x 40cm, as well as a couple of larger ones.
Wielding a handled rolling pin can be difficult and I like the control I have using a large fondant-style rolling pin made from polyethylene. Mine is a 500mm Loyal rolling pin.
I’m hopeless at rolling anything out evenly. No matter how hard I tried, my pastry was always thicker in the middle and thinner towards the edges. I use acrylic rolling guides made in Melbourne by Cutter Craft. They look like long rulers and come in different heights. I use them any time I’m baking pastry or rolled biscuits.
For this shortcrust pastry I use 4.5mm guides. Most pastry chefs roll pastry to around 2.5mm, but that’s way too thin for a home baker to manage without a pastry disaster.
No rolling guides? There are now quite a few rolling pins on the market that come with guide rings you slide onto each end. Loyal makes one with 2mm, 3.5mm and 4.5mm rings. And you can improvise with two strips of hobby wood of the same thickness.
Lining the tart tin
When lining a tart tin with straight sides, my routine is to line the sides first and then insert a base cut to size. This is similar to the method patisserie chefs use when they line mini tart shells. I find if you attempt to use a large circle of pastry, you end up with the pastry cracking and too much excess pastry around the sides of the tin. A circle will work in a more traditional pie dish with sloping sides, usually meant for pies with a top and bottom crust.
As a general rule, you need about two-thirds of the pâte brisée dough to line the sides and one-third (about 400g) for the base insert.
Remove the all-butter shortcrust pastry from the fridge and let it soften until it’s around 15°C. In my kitchen that can take anything from 30 minutes to a couple of hours, depending on the weather. In the Queensland summer, I run the air-conditioning at full blast while I’m rolling out pastry. It’s OK if the dough gets a bit soft, as the butter will firm up again in the fridge before you blind bake the tart shell.
Make sure you have a shelf available in your fridge (or freezer) to chill the rolled dough between each step.
Make an egg wash using 2 egg yolks and 1-2 tablespoons full cream milk.
To line a 30cm diameter, 3.5cm high, fluted tart tin, roll out two-thirds of the dough between two 30cm x 40cm silicone mats using 4.5mm rolling guides (4mm will also work fine). Return the dough to the fridge or freezer until well chilled.
Remove the top silicone mat and cut strips of dough to form the sides of the tart shell using a pastry wheel and ruler. I lightly dust flour across the top of the pastry to stop the ruler from sticking. Mark out strips 6cm wide and cut the strips with the pastry wheel. Return the strips on the silicone mat to the fridge to firm up so they will come away without sticking.
I use non-stick tart tins, but I also butter the base of the tin to help ensure the tart comes away clean when baked.
Next, line the sides of the tin with the strips of pastry. The goal is to have the pastry cover about 1cm of the base, run up the side of the tin and continue past the top of the tin by up to 2cm. Lightly press the strips to the side of the tin as you go. Overlap the strips when needed, use the egg wash to help seal the overlapped edges and gently press the seal. Once the entire tin is lined, continue pressing the pastry into the fluted sides.
Any excess height will be trimmed off after the shell is blind baked. But one extra step now gives you a sturdier edge, so it’s less fragile when you trim it level with the tin and when you serve the finished bake. Working around the tin, fold the excess dough back on itself, towards the inside of the tin, so the fold sits just above the top edge of the tin. Gently press the two layers of pastry together and into the fluted curves of the tin. That double layer sitting just proud of the rim allows for some shrinkage during baking and leaves you enough pastry to trim back to a neat, even top edge.
Next, gently press the pastry that overlaps onto the base down onto the base of the tin. Return the lined tin to the fridge to firm up while you roll out the shortcrust pastry dough for the base.
While the top of the 30cm tart tin matches that measurement, the bottom has a smaller diameter, and the pastry strips already cover the outer edge of the base. So I cut a template out of card (or find a plate or pot lid of the right diameter) several centimetres smaller. For a 30cm round tin, I use a 27cm round template for the pâte brisée base insert.
Roll the remaining shortcrust pastry dough between the two silicone mats to 4.5mm thick, with or without rolling guides. Chill the rolled dough until firm.
Next, remove the top mat and lightly dust the top of the rolled dough with flour, brushing away any excess. This will stop the template from sticking to the dough. Cut out a 27cm circle of dough.
Brush egg wash over the pastry that overlaps the base of the tin. Then lay the pastry circle in the tin so its edge sits on the egg-washed overlap, and press the two layers together to seal the join.
Then dock the base with a fork or a pastry docker. Return the lined tart tin to the fridge and chill for at least 3 hours. It may also be frozen at this stage and blind baked later.
Blind baking the tart shell
Preheat the oven to 180°C conventional or 160°C fan forced.
Place the lined tart tin on a baking tray so that it’s easy to move in and out of the oven without disturbing the loose base of the tin. I use oven roasting bags instead of baking paper to line the pastry shell. I find they’re less likely to stick to the par-baked pastry than baking paper, and they fit the shell more snugly when your chosen pie weights are added.
While I do own ceramic pie weights, I usually use a combination of dried beans and pearl couscous. I reuse this mix and keep it in a sealed container between bakes. I’ve been reusing this mix for quite some time.
Bake the tart shell for 15 to 20 minutes.
Bring the edges of the oven bag together to form a parcel and carefully lift the beans out of the tin (have a heatproof container ready for the beans). Brush the inside of the tart shell well with the egg wash. Don’t worry if the base looks a bit raw at this stage. Return the tart shell to the oven and continue baking until the crust is a light golden brown and looks almost fully baked, 5 to 10 minutes more.
Make sure you cool the blind baked tart shell completely before taking the next step.
Using a swivel vegetable peeler, gently scrape away the excess pastry along the top edge of the pastry shell until the crust is even with the top of the tart tin. Brush out the excess pastry crumbs from the bottom of the tart shell.
The homemade shortcrust pastry shell is now blind baked and ready for your filling of choice, to be added and baked according to that recipe’s instructions.
The 30cm fluted pâte brisée tart shell is perfect for my Zucchini Spiral Tart with Green Pea Salsa Verde recipe.
All-Butter Shortcrust Pastry (Pâte Brisée)

Equipment
- Digital kitchen scales
- Instant read thermometer
- Stand mixer with pastry beater or paddle attachment (or a food processor)
- Bench scraper
- 2 Silicone mats (or baking paper)
- 4.5mm rolling guides (optional)
- 30cm x 3.5cm fluted non-stick tart tin with a loose base
- Pastry wheel
- 27cm round template (card, a plate or a pot lid)
- Oven roasting bag (or baking paper)
- Pie weights (or dried beans and pearl couscous)
Ingredients
Pastry dough:
- 625 g all-purpose flour
- 315 g unsalted butter
- 90 g egg yolks
- 1 ½ teaspoons table salt
- 60 g iced water – inclusive of 1 teaspoon apple cider vinegar
Egg wash:
- 2 egg yolks
- 1-2 tablespoons of full cream milk
Instructions
Get organised:
- Clear space in your fridge or freezer to hold the measured ingredients, the rolled-out pastry dough and the lined tart tin.
- Weigh 315g chilled unsalted butter and cut it into 1.5cm cubes. Store in a sealed container in the fridge until needed.
- Weigh 625g all-purpose flour and 1½ teaspoons table salt into another sealed container and refrigerate.
- If you like, chill the stand mixer bowl and pastry beater (or the food processor bowl and blade) before you start.
Make the egg mix:
- Add a handful of ice cubes to a 250ml jug, top with cold water and set aside.
- Place a 500ml jug on your digital kitchen scales and zero the scales. Add 1 teaspoon apple cider vinegar, then iced water (without the ice cubes) to the weight of 60g.
- Zero the scales again. Separate 5 large eggs, adding the yolks to the jug one at a time until you have 90g of yolk. If you’re slightly short, make up the weight with a little of the leftover egg white.
- Whisk until well combined and refrigerate until required.
Make the pastry dough:
- Add the flour, salt and chilled butter cubes to the stand mixer bowl with the pastry beater attachment. Mix on low, up to a maximum of speed 2, until the mixture resembles coarse sand.
- With the mixer on low, gradually drizzle in the egg mix until the dough comes together and starts to form large lumps, then stop. Don’t overmix.
- If using a food processor, pulse the flour, salt and butter until the mixture resembles coarse sand. With the motor running, drizzle in the egg mix and stop when the dough starts to clump together.
Finish the dough on the bench:
- Turn the dough out onto the bench. No flour is needed. Using a pastry scraper, gather the lumps together and press into a rough loaf shape.
- Cut the dough in half with the pastry scraper, stack the two pieces, press down firmly and reshape into a rough loaf. Repeat 3 to 4 times. The dough doesn’t need to look perfectly cohesive.
- Shape the dough into a rectangle with the pastry scraper, then wrap it in plastic wrap or place it in a sealed container. Rest in the fridge for at least 3 hours, or overnight.
Line the tart tin:
- Remove the dough from the fridge and let it soften until it’s around 15°C, which takes 30 minutes to a couple of hours, depending on the weather.
- Make the egg wash by mixing 2 egg yolks with 1-2 tablespoons full cream milk.
- Roll out two-thirds of the dough between two 30cm x 40cm silicone mats, using 4.5mm rolling guides. Chill until well chilled.
- Remove the top mat and lightly dust the pastry with flour. Using a ruler and pastry wheel, mark and cut 6cm wide strips. Return the strips on the mat to the fridge until firm.
- Butter the base of a 30cm x 3.5cm fluted non-stick tart tin.
- Line the sides of the tin with the strips so the pastry covers about 1cm of the base, runs up the side and stands up to 2cm above the rim. Lightly press the strips to the side as you go. Where strips overlap, seal the join with egg wash and press gently. Once the tin is lined, press the pastry into the fluted sides.
- Working around the tin, fold the excess pastry back on itself towards the inside, so the fold sits just above the top edge of the tin. Press the two layers together and into the flutes.
- Press the pastry that overlaps the base down onto the base of the tin. Return the lined tin to the fridge to firm up.
- Roll the remaining dough (about 400g) between the silicone mats to 4.5mm thick. Chill until firm.
- Remove the top mat, lightly dust the dough with flour and brush away the excess. Using a 27cm round template, cut out a circle.
- Brush egg wash over the pastry that overlaps the base of the tin. Lay the pastry circle in the tin so its edge sits on the egg-washed overlap, and press the two layers together to seal.
- Dock the base with a fork or pastry docker. Chill the lined tin for at least 3 hours. It can also be frozen at this stage and blind baked later.
Blind bake the tart shell:
- Preheat the oven to 180°C conventional or 160°C fan forced.
- Place the lined tart tin on a baking tray. Line the pastry shell with an oven roasting bag and fill it with pie weights, or a mix of dried beans and pearl couscous.
- Bake for 15 to 20 minutes.
- Gather the edges of the bag into a parcel and carefully lift out the weights into a heatproof container. Brush the inside of the tart shell well with egg wash.
- Return to the oven for 5 to 10 minutes more, until the crust is light golden brown and looks almost fully baked.
- Cool the tart shell completely.
- Using a swivel vegetable peeler, gently scrape away the excess pastry along the top edge until it’s level with the tin. Brush out the crumbs.
- The tart shell is ready for your filling of choice.